--------------------------------
<1> . : .. , . ., 1956; .. . ., 1957; .. . ., 1961; .. . ., 1968; .. . ., 1985.
<2> . : .. . ., 2007; .. : . ., 2010.
<3> . : .. . - . 4- . ., 1913. . 628 - 636, 639; .. . ., 1913. . 315 - 320; .. . 4- . ., 1915. . II. . 551 - 562.
, , <1>. , , " ". , - , . : - , . , "" . , .
--------------------------------
<1> . , 4 . 27 .
, , , - . , , , , , , . , , - , , , , , .
|
|
, , () . -, , , - , , , "". -, , 1 2013 ., .
2. ()
, <1>. , (, ), , ( ). , , () ( . 3 ) <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> 25 2005 . N 42-.
<2> , ( ) (.: ECHR, Nikitin v. Russia, judgment of 20 July 2004; ECHR, Sabayev v. Russia, judgment of 8 April 2010; ECHR, Tumilovich v. Russia, judgment of 22 June 1999; ECHR, Galina Pitkevich v. Russia, judgment of 8 February 2001; ECHR, Ryabykh v. Russia, judgment of 24 July 2003, 56 - 58; ECHR, Radchikov v. Russia, judgment of 24 May 2007; ECHR, v. Romania, judgment of 28 October 1999).
, (res judicata) <1>, , , . , , res judicata <2>. , ( - ) , , res judicata <3>.
--------------------------------
<1> res judicata . 2 . 24 .
<2> 5 2007 . N 2- " 16, 20, 112, 336, 376, 377, 380, 381, 382, 383, 387, 388 389 , "" "", " (. 4); ECHR, Pravednaya v. Russia, judgment of 18 November 2004, 25; ECHR, Nelyubin v. Russia, judgment of 2 November 2006, 22.
|
|
<3> ECHR, Bratyakin v. Russia, judgment of 9 March 2006.
, , (. 401.15 ); 6 . , , , () .
, : -, ( ). -, (, ) .
, . 1 . 401.2 , , , , , , . , .
, <1>, , . , , - . (. . 53.2, 53.3 . 5 ) <2>. , . 401.2 , , ( , , ). : , , , . , , , . , <3> . 47.1 (. 127 ) <4>.
--------------------------------
<1> 23 1999 . N 5- " . 133, . 1 . 218 . 220 .. , .. , .. , .. "" (. 3); 27 2000 . N 11- " . 1 . 47 . 2 . 51 .. " (. 2); 14 2011 . N 16- " . 4 . 1 . 24 . 1 . 254 .. .. " (. 2.1).
|
|
<2> . 5 . 27 .
<3> 29 2010 . N 433- , (., : .. : . .... . . . ., 2014. . 10, 11, 16).
<4> , . , ( , , , , , ) , ( ), .
, , : , , ; , ; , , , ; ; , ; , , , .
, , , , , . , , , , , , <1>; , , <2> .
--------------------------------
<1> .: 38 19 2013 . N 41 " , ".
<2> 26 1997 . N 1- " " (. 23 2015 .) (. 3 . 1 . 29).
, . , , - , (. 2 . 401.4 ). , .
|
|
, . : , . , , . ., , , , , ( 25 2013 . N 128-13) <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> , , , .
, , . 4 . 29 () , , , , () <1>. , , , , , , .
--------------------------------
<1> 28 2014 . N 2 " 47.1 - , " (. 2 . 2).
, . . , , (, , , ), , .. . , , "", "". , ex officio , , <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> 1 17 1992 . N 2202-1 " " ( . 28 2015 .).
, - . <1>. , : , , ; .
--------------------------------
<1> ., : 3 2002 . N 28 " " (. 9.8); 17 2006 . N 61 " " (. 9.9); 20 2007 . N 185 " " ( . 26 2008 .) (. 13.4).
3.
- , . , . , , , .
|
|
. , , - "" .
, , , : 1) , , , , , () ; 2) (. 401.3 ).
, , , , , () , , , , . ( ) : ( ) ( ) <1>. , , <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> 3 28 2014 . N 2.
<2> . 47.1 : ( ) , , , , . , , - . 28 2013 . N 382- " 401.3 - " . . 2, 5 . 2 . 401.3 , , : " " " ". , , 28 2013 ., ( 25 2014 . N 8- " 401.3, 401.5, 401.8 401.17 - .. , .. ").
( ) , .
, . , , , . - <1>. , , , <2>. , , ( - - - ), , , , - ( - ). , , , .
--------------------------------
<1> . 2 . 30 .
<2> ., : .. // Lex Russica ( ). 2010. N 3. . 431 - 432.
4.
1. . , "" , , <1>. , , . , , , <2>. , : , , , , , , . in favorem, .. " " - . - : (in favorem), (in defavorem) .
--------------------------------
<1> . 3 . 28 .
<2> .: .. // . 2012. N 11.
. 401.16 , , , , .. . , , , (), . : , , , , , , <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> , . 401.6 " , , " . () in defavorem , () . , 28 2014 . N 2 (. 4 . 21), , , .
, , . in defavorem , , , , . , , , . 6 .