1918 .
, , 1917 1918 .., , 1980 ..
.
, .[1]
, 1918 . [2]
, , , 1917 , .
, 1917 .
, , , .
.
The Origin of the Communist Autocracy [3] , 1918 , , , . . , , , .
. , , 1987 The Mensheviks after October. Socialist opposition and the rise of the Bolshevik dictatorship[4], - 1918 , .
|
|
, , , . , .
, . , , , , .
, , .
.. 1918 , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , [5].
, , 1918 , , - , 1917 , . , , , - .
, : 33 , , , , . [6]
, , .
, 1918 , .
, , , , , , .
, .
.
. . [7]
.
5 , 12 , 8 , - 1918 .
|
|
, 9 , [8].
, .
. . , , . 22 , , , . .[9]
, , 1918 , [10]
. , 18 1918 ., :
, - . . - , , . . , . , 20- . . , 6 , . // . , : , , [] . .. 18 1918 . , . .. 25 1918 . , [11]
, , , .
, , [12]
, .
, 1918 .
|
|
, .
, , , , , , 1918 - , , - .
, .
, - , , , , , . . . . .
, , , .
, , 1918 ., - . 1917 . 1918 . 350 . 150 [13]
1918 , . 1500 , , , , [...] ... , , 100 000 , .. [...] , .[14]
, :
1) 1917 1918 . ., - , , , 24 % , (22,4 % );
2) 1917 , , , , ;
|
|
3) , , ;
4) 1918 , ;
5) , , , , 1918 ;
6) , , , ;
7) , , , , ;
8) , , ;
9) , ;
10) , .
.., , , .
[1] .. 1918. ., 1982;
[2] .., .. .., 1988;
[3] Shapiro L. The Origin of the Communist Autocracy. Political Opposition in the Soviet State. 1917-1922. N.Y. 1965;
[4] Brovkin V. The Mensheviks after October. Socialist opposition and the rise of the Bolshevik dictatorship. N.Y., 1987;
[5] .. . 1918 , ., 1998;
[6] .. . 1918 , ., 1998;
[7] " ". 1917-1929. . . .: - , 2000. . 11;
[8] " ". 1917-1929. . . .: - , 2000;
[9] " ". 1917-1929. . . .: - , 2000. . 11.
[10]
[11] () . . . : . 1917 1929: . . - / . . ... .: .-. . , 2000. . 57-58 : 1917-1918 . / . .. // . 1993. - 1. . 160-161;
http://www.istprof.atlabs.ru/1149.html;
[12]
[13] http://oldhat.ru/20vek/142.htm
[14] " ". 1917-1929. . . .: - , 2000. . 12.