--------------------------------
<1> , , in favorem.
<2> 360, 410 ( . 18 2001 .).
<3> 360, 410 ( . 8 2003 .).
, , , . . . 1 . 412.12 , , , . - , " " . , <1>. .
--------------------------------
<1> ECHR, Galich v. Russia, judgment of 13 May 2008.
, " " . (. 126 ) <1>. " ": , ex nunc, , . , , " . - - " <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> ECHR, Beian v. Romania, judgment of 6 December 2007, 39.
<2> 21 2010 . N 1- " 4 170, 1 311 1 312 " "", "", " "" "- "" (. 1 . 3.4).
|
|
. , , ( ) (. 621 ). , - <1>. , , , . , , , , , .
--------------------------------
<1> .., .., .. . . . 398.
2. . , , . .
2.1. . , , , . . 1 2 . 401.2 ( ). . , <1>. - , ( , ) <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> . 2 . 29 .
<2> . 3 . 412.3 , , .
2.2. . , , . , <1>, . ( ) <2>. , .. , , , , ( ). <3>.
|
|
--------------------------------
<1> . 5 . 29 .
<2> , , .
<3> ECHR, Sejdovic v. Italy, judgment of 1 March 2006, 86; ECHR, Aldoshkina v. Russia, judgment of 12 October 2006, 24; ECHR, Stanislav Zhukov v. Russia, judgment of 12 October 2006, 24; ECHR, Stadukhin v. Russia, judgment of 18 October 2007, 30; ECHR, Alekseyenko v. Russia, judgment of 8 January 2009, 65; ECHR, Sibgatullin v. Russia, judgment of 23 April 2009, 46.
2.3. . . : 1) , ; 2) . , . . , . , ( ), ( ).
, 3 . 29 , , . , , , - , , ( ), . .
, , , (. 412.3 ). , .
31.
.. . ., 1959; .. . ., 1968; .., .. . ., 1982; .. . ., 1999; .. : . ., 2011; .., .., .. . ., 2015.
|
|
1.
.
1. . (, ) , , : , - , .. . , , , , .
, , , , . ( ) , - (, ). (, , , ), , , (, , ).
, . , ( ) , , . , . , . () <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: 16 2007 . N 6-; 23 2009 . " ".
, ( ), . , () . , , , . - ( ).
2. - . , <1>. , XVI . 1958 .: , , , <2>. - in favorem ( ) <3>. , , ( ), , ( ) <4>. , , - , , , <5> ( - ). , , "" .
|
|
--------------------------------
<1> ., : Mommsen T. Strafrecht. In: Systematisches Handbuch der Deutschen Rechtswissenschaft. Leipzig, 1899. S. 153 - 154.
<2> 622 .
<3> , 2003 . ( ) . in defavorem ( ) (., , : Pradel J. Droit . Paris, 2008. P. 470).
<4> ., : Pradel J. . Paris, 2010. P. 792.
<5> (. . 2 2 ).
1864 ., , " " (Wiederaufnahme eines Verfahrens) <1>. " , ". , , .. <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: . . 359 - 373 .
<2> 934 - 935, 938 1864 .
, reformatio in pejus ( ) ( , ..), ", , ... , , , , " <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> 384 1960 .
, ( ) (, ) . ( ) , , , , 1960 . , . , , , , (, ; , , ..), . , - , ( , - , , ..), . " ", .
|
|
, " ", " ", .. , . " ", "", "", (), . , , ( , , ). - , , .
3. . " " : 1) 2) . : (. 49 ). , .
, res judicata, . non bis in idem ( ), , , , . , , .. , , , res judicata , .
, - <1>. , , . , - "" <2>. , , ( , ) .
--------------------------------
<1> . 2 .
<2> . 2 .
- , , , . , () .
, . , , , . , , , .
. , (in propria causa nemo judex, ), <1>, , <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> 2 . 417 .
<2> , , . , . 623-1 , .
( 2002 . - ) <1>. , , , , . <2> . (. 18 ) (, , <3>) , (, , ..) <4>.
--------------------------------
<1> , , . , : (. : Pradel J. . P. 809).
<2> . . 1 .
<3> , , , () . , , ( ), . 3 . 133 . , , ( ) . 18 (. . 32 ).
<4> 15 2014 . N 144-13; 6 2013 . N 13-13; 10 2013 . N 99-13.
, ; . , ( ) , , .
4. . , , , ( 2010 ., , ) <1>. , "", "" , . , .