" " . .. , . .. .. , .., , . (., .).
" " , . , .
: , . : . : , .
.
. . .
" " . , .
.
, "" , , .
(natural kinds , . , . .) , "", "", "" .
, , .
. ("- "), , .
( " " ) , , .. (. , ).
(, , ) . : , .
( . intentio ) ; () .
, , , .
|
|
- , ; , , .
, ; , "". . (, , ) " " ().
, . , . , , , , , -, -, -. , , , .
, .
" " . ; . , , , , .
, ; : , , , .
( . ) , .
( . conventio ) , () , .. , . , .
" " ( .) , .
( . contra dictio , ) , .. , - .
"" . , , , , ..
-, , " " , , . , , , , , ; , , . .
|
|
" " .
" " . , , ( ) ( ) , , .
" " ( ), , "" .
"- " (Tractatus Ligico-philosophicus) . . . 1921 . . .
( " " . ) (. , ).
: "", "", ""); , "", "" ..; , , , , ; ; "", ""; "", "". , - .
( . modus , ) , ( .), , , ( .). . . , , .. , (. de dicto) , , (. de re). . .
, (), .. , .
( . natura ) , . , , . - . , , . , " " .
. , , , , , , , .
|
|
.
( " " . ) , (. , ).
(, ).
.
, "" (parsing down) (parsing up).
"" ( . ) , .
" " (. Sachverhalt) , " "; "" (. Tatsache), .
"" (. ) , .
" " , .
, , .
, ; .
(. propositional attitudes) , , , , -. . ". " , , .. . . . . , . . .
, - .
, . .
. , , " " , , " " .
" " . , , , , .
: , ""; , .. , .
" " "" : . , , , .
|
|
, . , ; , () , - .
, , .
(. relevant- , ) .
(. relevant ) .
, , " ". , , "" , , (.. ) .
, ( ), . , "denotation" "connotation", , "Sinn" "Bedeutung". "reference" 1952 [790]
() , , .
.
.
( ) . . . .
, ., , , .
, .
, , , ( ).
" ", .
"-" ( ) , - , .. , .
, ( ); " " , .
" " (Philosophische Untersuchungen) . . ".." 1953 . ( ). , "" , "- " .
, .
, , (, , ).
" " . , "" . " ", .
_____________
[1] Urmson J.O. Philosophical Analysis. Oxford: Clarendon, 1956, p.vii
[2] . : (). ., 1988. .434.
[3] , , , ( "") , . , , -, , .
|
|
[4] Smith Barry. Austrian Philosophy: The Legacy of Franz Brentano. La Salle and Chicago: Open Court, 1994.
[5] Simons Peter. Philosophy and Logic in Central Europe. Dordrecht, 1992.
[6] . -. ., 1987. .104.
[7] . - . ., 1958. 4.003.
[8] . . (). . 523.
[9] Smith Barry. Austrian Philosophy: The Legacy of Franz Brentano. La Salle - Chicago: Open Court, 1994. . 44.
[10] . . ., "", 2000. .13.
[11] ., . " ". .: . . (.) XIX-XX . . 1. ., 1964.
[12] .: . . ., -, 1999. . 135-142.
[13] .: ... - .
http://www.philosophy.ru/library/dombrovski/01.html
* (.).
[14] . . . ... . "", 2002.
[15] . .
[16] R. Ingarden. Z badań nad filozofia wspólczesna. Warszawa, 1963. S.196-197.
[17] , .-. : . , . . , , , ( .. // . 1992. 8. .80).
[18] Russell B. Mysticism and logic and other essays. London: Allen & Unwin LTD, 1954. P.76.
[19] , , . . , . (Hacker P.M.S. Semantic Holism: Frege and Wittgenstein // Wittgenstein: sources and perspectives. New York, 1979. P.214).
[20] . . ., , 1997. .26.
[21] Geach P. Mental acts: their content and their objects. .136.
[22] , . 30.
[23] , . 25.
[24] , .25-26.
[25] , .26.
[26] .
[27] A. Whitehead and B. Russel. Principia Mathematica. Vol. I. Cambridge, 1925. 2. ed., p. 30: , , - - (the so-and-so) - .
[28] . . .32.
[29] Kripke S. Wittgenstein on Rules and Private Language. Ox., 1982. .197.
[30] Geach Peter. Mental acts: their content and their objects. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul 1957. .137.
[31] . . .151
[32] Geach P. Mental acts: their content and their objects. .139.
[33] ., .-. .. 1966. .227.
[34] Geach P. Mental acts: their content and their objects. .136-137.
[35] . . .30.
[36] , .28-29.
[37] , .29-30.
[38] , .27.
[39] .
[40] , .40.
[41] . . . . . ... , "", 2000.
[42] . . ., , 1975. .153.
[43] . . .27.
[44] . . .26.
[45] , : " - , , , , , (), , " ( . . .: , 1969. .20).
[46] , . 31, 1.
[47] . . .37.
[48] . . .31
[49] .
[50] , .32.
[51] , .32-33.
[52] , .22.
[53] , .55.
[54] , . 33, 1.
[55] . . .35.
[56] Frege G. Grundgesetze. S.9.
[57] Ibid. S.10.
[58] , .35.
[59] , .38.
[60] , .35.
[61] , .56.
[62] , .61.
[63] .
[64] , .70.
[65] , .64-65.
[66] , . 65.
[67] . . ., , 1999. .49-50.
[68] Bradley P.H. The Principles of Logic. L., 1883, p. 95.
[69] Russell B. My Philosophical Development. L. N.Y., 1959. P.133.
[70] .: . . ., "-", 1998. .156-164.
[71] . - . ., 1987. .259
[72] . ( I). ., , 1994. .338.
[73] . . . ., C.50.
[74] ., : . . : , 1999. .31.
[75] Russell B. Our Knowledge of the External World. London: George Allen & Unwin, LTD, 1926. P.47.
[76] . . .: , 1996. .155-156.
[77] Frege G. Philosophical and Mathematical Correspondence. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1980. P.130.
[78] . . .90.
[79] . .88.
[80] . . .2;13.
[81] . .123.
[82] . . .91.
[83] . . : ..., 1914. .35.
[84] .
[85] . .36.
[86] . .44.
[87] , , , , . .
[88] . .89.
[89] . .92.
[90] . .94.
[91] Russell B. Theory of Knowledge: The 1913 Manuscript // The Collected Papers of Bertrand Russell. London: Allen & Unwin, 1984. P.100.
[92] Ibid. P.101.
[93] Ibid. P.98.
[94] Ibid. P.99.
[95] Russell B. Misticism and logic. P.111.
[96] : Wright G.H.von The Origin of Wittgensteins Tractatus Wittgenstein L. Prototractatus. P.2-34.
[97] , , ., , : , , , , (Wittgenstein L. Letters to C.K.Ogden. Oxford, Basil Blakwell, 1973. P.21).
[98] . 1914-1916. . ... , "", 1998. .57.
[99] , , , Der Satz () .. (.: .. . .169).
[100] , ջ, . (Wittgensteins Tractatus, P.220), (., . // . 1994. 6), . , , . (. .170) , , ջ, .
[101] , , : Pears D. Wittgenstein. Fontana/Collins, 1971.
[102] , : , : , , , (, .157).
[103] . . - . .:. ., 1958. .11-12.
[104] , .: , , , (Frege G. On the Scientific Justification of a Concept-script // Mind, 1964, 290. P.157-158). , , , - , . , . , , , (Wittgenstein L. Letters to Russel, Keyns and Moore. P.71).
[105] (, , , , ), , , , , .
[106] . 1914-1916. .61.
[107] , .62.
[108] , . 27.
[109] , .105.
[110] , , [4.1121]. .
[111] , .73.
[112] , , .
[113] , . 111.
[114] Wittgenstein L. Letters to Russell, Keyns and Moore. P.71. , . . , , , .. .
[115] , : , , , , : , : ? ? : , , , ; , , . : - , , -. . , . , . , ( . , 1996, 5. .114).
[116] Wittgenstein L. Briefe an Ludwig von Ficker. Salzburg: Verlag Otto Müller, 1969. S.35-36.
[117] 1916-1918. .37.
[118] . .17.
[119] . .114.
[120] , , , (.: . : - , .: , 1994. .210-216), . , , . , , .
[121] 1916-1918. .86.
[122] , , , , , .
[123] . Introduction to Wittgensteins Tractatus ( , , Fogelin R.J. Wittgenstein. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London, 1976. P.49) , , abcd. , : abcd , abc() a()()d, , fx, (x,y) ; abcd fd, (b,c) (P.101). . , ; ()()()() , (.101). , , , ; , (.110). . -, , , . , , . -, a priori abcd, , . , [5.554] [5.5571]. , , , . .
[124] 3.326: , , . .. , . , , 钻 (Letters to C.K.Ogden. P.59).
[125] : , , , , , (Prototractatus, 2.0122). , f, , , .
[126] Prototractatus : : , [3.20103]. [3.233.251]. , , .
[127] , , a b , , . , , , .
[128] , , , . (, 3.1432), . , , ; R, . , (., , Griffin J. Wittgensteins Logical Atomism, Ch.II, , , [4.24], ) .
[129] , , , 1930. . , , . , , : . , , , , . , , . , , : , , , , .. , , , , , , (Wittgenstein L. Philosophical Remarks. The University of Chicago Press, 1975. P.301). .. , , , . aRb. , aRb , a R b, . , aRb .
[130] , , , , : Copi J.M. Objects, Propreties and Relations in the Tractatus // Mind, Vol.57, 266, 1958. P.145165 ( Essays on Wittgensteins Tractatus), . . , , , , , , . . 3.1432, , , , . , , , . , aRb , a b, , fa. , , , . . (Sellars W. Naming and Sayng // Essays on Wittgensteins Tractatus, P.249-270; Sellars W. Truth and Correspondence // The Journal of Philosophy, Vol.LIX, 2, 1962. P. 29-56), f , a . , , . , fa ga, , : a a. : -, , . , , . -, , , . 2.03, : , . , , (Philosophical Remarks, P.303). -, 3.1432 R, , , . -, , , , . , . , , . . (Evans E. About aRb // Essays on Wittgensteins Tractatus. P.195-199). , R aRb , , , aRb, bRa, aRb , bRa. R , - : aR , R , a . , , . . , R . . , , , , , .
[131] , . , . . , (. ), , , .
[132] 1916-1918. .54.
[133] : ~ ( ). , (.46(1,2)).
[134] , , (Bild), , . , . . , , .
[135] , , ., : . F G , F, (Stenius E. Wittgensteins Tractatus. P.95).
[136] Schwyzer H.R.G. Wittgensteins Picture Theory of Language // Essays on Wittgensteins Tractctus. , . , , . : , , , , , , , , , (das Vorstellen) , , , , , , - (), , ; , (.278). , . . , . ; .
[137] , , , , . (Abbildung) ; (Darstellung) . ., : [2.12]. , . [2.15; 2.151], [2.1513; 2.1514]. , , [2.16; 2.161]; , [2.17]. , . - , : (Darstellung) (Abbildung). Darstellung [2.22; 2.221-2.224]; : , (darstellt), [2.221] (Ricœur P. Husserl and Wittgenstein on Language // Analytic Philosophy and Phenomenology. The Hague, Martinus Nijhoff, 1976. P.90).
[138] , , . 3.02 3 2.221 , . , . , , .
[139] (.: . .22(9)), . : . , . . , . , , , , () . , , , - , ( .. . ( ) // : . .15).
[140] ., , , (.: Kenny A. Wittgenstein. P.52-53).
[141] 1916-1918. .23.
[142] , , , , . , , , .
[143] Prototractatus , [3.2].
[144] .: 2.063.
[145] Tatsache Sachverhalt , . , , . , .. (.496). Sachverhalt Tatsache . , , (. ). Copi J.M. Tractatus 5.542 // Essays on Wittgensteins Tractatus, P.165. Sachverhalt Tatsache . . (p.cit. P.29). , .
[146] : Sachverhalt , Elementarsatz, . Tatsache , , (, .156). (.15).
[147] , . , , . , . Gegenstand , , , , , ( . : // : . .: , 1993. .85). , Gegenstand . . , , , Gegenstand , , , Gegenstand . , , , (. ).
[148] , , mutatis mutandis, ., : , , , , .... , , , , (Hacker P.M.S. Semantic Holism: Frege and Wittgenstein, .231-232). , , .
[149] . , , . : Wolniewicz B. A Parallelism between Wittgensteinian and Aristotelian Ontologies // Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science. Dordrecht,1969, IV. Gegenstand . , . , , , , , , , . , .
[150] : [], (Letters to C.K.Ogden, P.59). , - , , , .
[151] , , : , - .. . , , (.72(10)). .
[152] .: (Stenius E. Wittgensteins Tractatus, P.43).
[153] , . , , . , , , , , , , , . .
[154] : , , (Letters to C.K.Ogden. P.23).
[155] : , ( . // : . .: , 1998. .50).
[156] , . . , , , , , .
[157] , .., , , : n , ... , , n 锻 (Lewy C. A Note of the Text of the Tractatus // Mind, 1961, vol.61). ( ) , , , .. , . .
[158] , . , - . , - . , , , . , , , , .
[159] .: , , , (Maslow A. A Study in Wittgensteins Tractatus. University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1961. P.24). , , . , . , . , , , (.26) . , . , . , , .
[160] (, . 11), , , . . . .
[161] 1916-1918. .87.
[162] .. , . : , , : , , [2.01]. , , (Finch H.L. Wittgenstein the Early Philosophy: an Exposition of the Tractatus.- New York: Humanities Press, 1971.- P.9). , , , , , , .. ; .. , , . , . ? , , .
[163] 1916-1918. .80.
[164] .
[165] . .92.
[166] . .91.
[167] . . ., -, 1999. .284-285.
[168] ., .: Schlick M. Meaning and Verification. The Philosophical Review, 45, 1946. P.152.
[169] Ibid. P.155.
[170] . (Konstatierungen).
[171] . . ., , 1975. .268-269.
[172] Ramsey F.P. Foundation of Mathematics. P. 275.
[173] . . ., , 1954. .22.
[174] , . 9-10.
[175] , . 29.
[176] Neurath O. 'Sociology and Physicalism' in: Ayer A.J. (ed.) Logical Positivism. P. 291.
[177] Neurath O. 'Protocol Sentences' in: Ayer A.J. (ed.) Logical Positivism, pp. 204 and 206.
[178] .: Hempel C.G. 'On the Logical Positivists' Theory of Truth' Analysis, v.2, No.4, 1935. Pp. 49-59.
[179] .: Carnap R. Logical Syntax of Language. N.Y., 1937.
[180] .: Hempel C.G. 'On the Logical Positivists' Theory of Truth', .56.
[181] Hemp